Last updated:  20.08.2026

Journal of Liberty and International Affairs is committed to publishing original, high-quality scholarly work that makes a meaningful contribution to the academic community. We strive to uphold the highest standards of research integrity, publication ethics, and editorial excellence, and we expect the same commitment from our authors, reviewers, and editors.

Honesty, originality, transparency, and fairness on the part of authors, together with objectivity, impartiality, confidentiality, and integrity on the part of editors and peer reviewers, are fundamental principles that guide the journal’s editorial and publishing processes.

The journal applies the Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and adheres to the ethical principles set out in the Singapore Statement on Research Integrity, thereby promoting the highest standards of research integrity and publication ethics. 

All parties involved in the publication of scholarly work, including authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher, are expected to comply with these ethical standards. The journal is fully committed to maintaining a transparent, fair, and ethical publishing environment, and all of its policies are freely accessible on the journal’s website.

 

EDITOR DUTIES:

Liability

The editor of a peer-reviewed journal is accountable for identifying which articles submitted to the journal need to be published and is accountable for the entirety published in the journal, according to the legal stipulations for defamation, copyright laws, and plagiarism. The editor might also consult with different editors or reviewers while making publication selections. The editor must uphold the academic record’s integrity, prevent business motives from compromising ethical and intellectual principles and be ready to publish corrections, clarifications, retractions, and apologies as necessary.

Honesty

The editor should evaluate the articles for scientific content regardless of the author’s race, gender, sexual orientation, confession, ethnic origin, citizenship, or political ideology. The editor will no longer discuss an article with anybody outside the author(s), peer-reviewers and potential peer-reviewers, and, in some cases, the editorial board members, as necessary.

Confidentiality

The corresponding author, peer-reviewers, potential peer-reviewers, other editorial consultants, and the publisher, where applicable, are the only parties to whom the editor and any editorial staff may disclose information on a submitted manuscript.

Disclosure, conflicts of interest, and other issues

When considering retracting, expressing concern, and issuing corrections concerning articles published in the Journal of Liberty and International Affairs, the editor may refer to COPE’s Guidelines for Retracting Articles as a guide.

Unpublished data disclosed in an article submission should no longer be used in the editor’s research without the author’s explicit written permission.

Confidential data or thoughts acquired via review have to be stored confidential and are now not used for personal benefit.

The editor must ensure that marketing, reprint, or other commercial revenue has no impact or impact on editorial selections. The editor must seek to ensure an appropriate peer-review procedure. Editors must withdraw from considering manuscripts if they have a conflict of interest with any of the authors, organizations, or (presumably) institutions involved in the articles due to any collaborative, competitive, or other relationships or connections they may have.

All authors should be required to disclose competing interests (or conflicts of interest), and editors should publish corrections if any are discovered after the article has been published. Along with releasing a retraction or statement of the situation, additional appropriate action may be required.

If you are uncertain, make sure to disclose any potential conflicts of interest or have a conversation with the editorial office. Submissions with undisclosed conflicts that come to light later may face rejection. If published articles are found to have undisclosed conflicts, they might require reassessment, publication of a correction, or in severe cases, retraction. For additional details on conflicts of interest, refer to the guidance provided by the WAME.

Involvement and cooperation in investigations

Editors must protect the integrity of the published material by pursuing any suspected or alleged research and publication wrongdoing and issuing corrections and retractions as necessary. Editors must investigate wrongdoing by peer-reviewers and editors. When ethical concerns are made about an article that has been submitted or an article that has been published, an editor must act reasonably quickly.

Generative AI policy for editors

Editors are not allowed to upload received articles into AI software to avoid compromising privacy and copyright.

REVIEWER DUTIES:

Contribution to editorial decisions

Peer-review helps the editor’s decision-making process and, through editorial correspondence with the author, can aid the author in improving the article text.

Agility

Any invited reviewer who feels inadequate to evaluate the article or is aware that a timely peer- review will not be possible must immediately inform the editor so that other reviewers can be contacted.

Confidentiality and discretion

All peer-reviewed articles must be treated as confidential files at all times. They cannot be discussed or presented to anyone else without the editor’s permission.

Peer-reviews must adhere to strict standards of objectivity. It is forbidden to make personal remarks about the authors. Reviewers must honestly state their opinions and provide appropriate justification.

Attribution of sources

Reviewers must locate relevant published works that the authors have not cited. Any allegation that a statement, conclusion, or line of reasoning has previously been stated must be accompanied by the proper citation. Reviewers must also draw the editor’s attention to any striking similarities or overlaps between the article under consideration and any other published materials they know firsthand.

Conflicts of interest and disclosure

Peer-reviewed material that contains private information, concepts or ideas should be kept secret and not used for personal advantage. Peer-reviewers can no longer consider evaluating articles with conflicts of interest because of collaborative, competitive, or other relationships or affiliations with any of the authors, businesses, or institutions associated with the article.

Generative AI policy for peer-reviewers

Peer reviewers must refrain from using AI tools to evaluate articles, ensuring the application of critical thinking and independent judgment as essential to this process. Generative AI and AI-assisted tools should not be used to assess the scientific content of a manuscript, as they may generate inaccurate, incomplete, or biased conclusions. Reviewers remain fully responsible and accountable for the content of their evaluation reports.

AUTHOR DUTIES:

Authorship

All submitted manuscripts must comply with the Journal of Liberty and International Affairs’ authorship standards to uphold transparency, accountability, and academic integrity.

Effective January 1, 2025, each article may list a maximum of three (3) authors. This limitation is intended to promote clarity regarding individual contributions.

Exception: Since July 2026, an exception has been granted exclusively for manuscripts resulting from European projects (e.g., Horizon Europe, Erasmus+, COST Actions, Marie Sklodowska-Curie Actions, and Interreg). In such cases, the official project title and grant number must be explicitly stated in the Acknowledgments or Funding section of the manuscript. Additionally, the corresponding author must provide a detailed justification and a comprehensive author contribution statement (Contributor Role Taxonomy - CRediT) outlining each individual's specific role. The editorial team reserves the right to request official proof of project involvement and to accept or reject submissions based on the credibility and quality of the justification. Furthermore, all listed authors must meet internationally recognized authorship criteria: (1) substantial contribution to the conception, design, data acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of the research; (2) drafting or critically revising the manuscript for significant intellectual content; (3) final approval of the version to be published; and (4) full accountability for all aspects of the work to ensure accuracy and integrity.

Honorary, guest, or gift authorship is strictly prohibited. If it is determined that one or more listed authors do not meet the required criteria, the manuscript will be rejected, and the responsible author(s) may be prohibited from future submissions to the Journal of Liberty and International Affairs.

For co-authored submissions, the corresponding author must provide written and signed permission from all co-authors (Permission for Multiple Co-Authorship), confirming their agreement to the submission. In addition, the Editorial Board requires the submission of a CRediT author statement (Contributor Roles Taxonomy), which must accurately reflect each contributor's role in the article. These contributions will be published alongside the final article.

The corresponding author must ensure that all qualified co-authors are appropriately listed in the article’s authorship, that no inappropriate authors are included, and that all co-authors have reviewed the final draft and given their approval for the article’s submission and potential publication.

Editors are permitted to publish their own articles in the journal; however, they are not allowed to be involved in the editorial handling or decision-making process of their own submissions. Such articles will be assigned to at least two independent external reviewers, and final decisions will be made by other editorial board members who have no conflicts of interest with the author(s).

The journal adheres to the COPE guidelines in evaluating authorship disputes and in addressing any allegations of authorship misconduct.

Authorship and AI tools

The integrity of academic publishing hinges on originality, intellectual contribution, and human-authored research. Therefore, it is crucial to address the use of AI tools responsibly. All articles will undergo a Grammarly AI check before being sent to reviewers to ensure we maintain complete control over the submitted data. Following COPE guidelines, artificial intelligence (AI) tools (e.g., ChatGPT) cannot be listed as authors in submitted articles. Authors are fully responsible for the content of their articles, including any parts generated by AI tools, and are thus liable for any inaccuracies or breaches of publication ethics. Following the EASE recommendations, authors who have used AI tools in developing their articles must include a statement in the AI declaration section specifying the technologies used and their purpose. This requirement does not apply to software such as spelling or grammar checkers or reference management tools.

Statement: During the preparation of this work, the author(s) used [NAME TOOL / SERVICE] in order to [REASON]. After using this tool/service, the author(s) reviewed and edited the content as needed and take(s) full responsibility for the content of the publication.

If misuse of generative AI tools is discovered after publication, the journal editors reserve the right to issue a correction or retract the article.

Authors can consult the EU's Living Guidelines on the Responsible Use of Generative AI in Research to ensure that generative AI is used responsibly in research.

Disclosure and conflicts of interest

All authors must disclose any financial or other significant conflicts of interest that could be perceived to influence the findings or their interpretation in the publication. Disclosure of all funding sources for the project is also required.

Fundamental errors

The author must contact the journal’s editor or publisher as soon as he or she becomes aware of a significant error or inaccuracy in his/her published article and work with them to either retract the article or publish an appropriate erratum.

Reporting standards

Authors who present original research findings should give a truthful assessment of the work done and an unbiased analysis of its relevance. The article should appropriately reflect the underlying data. An article should provide sufficient information and citations to enable others to replicate the work. False or deliberately inaccurate statements are unacceptable and constitute unethical behavior.

Originality and plagiarism

The authors must ensure that their articles are entirely original and that, if they have borrowed any ideas or words from others, they have properly cited or acknowledged the source.

Multiple, duplicate, or simultaneous publications

The authors are not permitted to publish submissions presenting the same study in multiple journals or primary publications. The simultaneous submission of the same article to multiple journals is unacceptable and constitutes unethical publishing.

Acknowledgment of sources

The authors should cite publications that helped define the character of the present research. Always give proper recognition to other people’s contributions.

PUBLISHER’S CONFIRMATION:

In the alleged or established fraudulent publication, scientific misconduct, plagiarism, or duplication, the publisher will closely work with the editors and take all necessary steps to clarify and correct the problematic article. In the worst scenarios, the affected article may be completely retracted. This case includes the quick release of an erratum.

COMPLIANCE WITH ETHICAL STANDARDS:

The authors should include informed consent if the research involved humans and a statement on the welfare of animals if the research involved animals, to ensure objectivity and transparency in the research and that accepted principles of ethical and professional conduct have been followed. When submitting an article, authors must add the statements (if appropriate) in a separate “Compliance with Ethical Standards” section before the References section.

If a waiver was obtained for the research, the authors must expressly state that fact, along with the justification for the waiver. They must attest that the research was carried out following the Declaration of Helsinki and any later revisions or comparable ethical guidelines.

Acknowledgments

Everyone who helped create the article’s content but did not satisfy the criteria for authorship should be acknowledged, including those who gave technical support, institutional or department chiefs who offered general encouragement, and medical writers. The journal expects authors to include this section in the article and write an acknowledgment even if they have no one to thank. In this case, the authors should write only: “not applicable”.

Funding

It is essential to disclose all funding sources for the research and their involvement in the study’s design, data collection, analysis, and interpretation, as well as the article’s authorship. Along with the grant numbers, provide the name of the financing entity or agencies. The journal expects authors to include this part before the References section and to write: “not applicable” if the research received no funding.

RESEARCH INVOLVING HUMAN PARTICIPANTS:

Human rights

When presenting a study that involved human subjects, authors should state that the study was carried out following the standards outlined in the Declaration of Helsinki and any later amendments or with comparable ethical standards and that the study has been approved by the appropriate institutional or national research ethics committee. Suppose there is doubt whether the research was carried out following the Declaration of Helsinki or other comparable standards. In that case, the authors must justify their strategy and show that the questionable portions of the research were expressly approved by an independent ethics committee or institutional review board.

Before the References section, the following statement needs to be added:

“All procedures performed in studies involving human participants were following the ethical standards of the institutional or national research committee and with the Declaration of Helsinki and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards”.

If the article does not contain empirical studies with human participants, state:

"This article does not contain any studies with human participants performed by any of the authors".

Journal Scope & Human Participant Policy

Effective August 2026, the Journal of Liberty and International Affairs no longer includes specific statements regarding research involving animals, as the journal exclusively publishes scholarly research in the social sciences, humanities, law, economics, and political studies. Accordingly, the journal does not publish clinical trials or experimental studies involving animals or human subjects.

Informed consent

Human rights belong to everyone and cannot be violated. Individuals who participate in studies have certain rights, including the ability to control what happens to any personal information collected about them, any statements they made during research or interview, and any photos that may have been taken. Therefore, each human participant must sign a written informed consent form before being included in the research. Unless the information is essential for scientific purposes and the participant (or parent or guardian if the participant is incapable) gave written informed consent for publication, identifiable characteristics (names, identity numbers, dates of birth, and other information) of the study participants may not be published in written descriptions, photos, or genetic profiles.

For empirical studies involving surveys, interviews, or other research with human participants, authors must confirm that informed consent was obtained from all participants and that participant privacy and confidentiality were strictly maintained. Such research must comply with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki, as amended or revised, where applicable, and with any other relevant internationally recognized ethical guidelines and institutional requirements.

Complete anonymity can be hard to achieve in some circumstances, and if there is any doubt, informed consent must be obtained. Authors must guarantee that alterations do not change the scientific meaning if identifiable characteristics are changed to protect anonymity, as in genetic profiles.

Before the References section, the following statement needs to be added:

 “Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study”.

The following statement needs to be added if the article contains identifiable participant characteristics:

“Additional informed consent was obtained from all individual participants for whom identifying information is included in this article”.

When requested during peer-review or after publication, the corresponding author must be ready to gather documentation of compliance with ethical standards and present it. False claims or failing to adhere to ethical standards will result in the author being held accountable.

Post-Publication Discussions and Corrections
Following COPE post-publication discussions and corrections, any comments fostering discussion or expressing concerns about the published content should be submitted as a Letter to the Editor-In-Chief. JLIA encourages unbiased, evidence-based comments that add value to scholarly discussions and refrain from subjective opinions or derogatory language. If post-publication discussions indicate a necessity to correct or retract the published content, the concerns will be addressed through a Correction or Retraction Notice.

The journal editors are always willing to publish corrections, clarifications, retractions, and apologies when needed.

Publisher’s note:
The publisher remains neutral concerning jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.