The Legalization of School Choice and Its Implications for Public Education and Democratic Citizenship

Main Article Content

Brian Fife

Abstract

The author examines the expansion of education vouchers and school choice policies in the United States, tracing their legal evolution and public policy impact. Following pivotal Supreme Court rulings such as Zelman v. Simmons-Harris (2002) and Carson v. Makin (2022), constitutional Establishment Clause protections separating church and State have diminished, enabling public taxpayer funds to subsidize private religious education. Using Indiana’s Choice Scholarship Program as a primary illustrative case study, the paper demonstrates how targeted initiative programs originally designed for low-income families can rapidly expand into universal voucher systems accessible to all households regardless of wealth. Framing school choice within the historical perspectives of Horace Mann and John Dewey, an argument is presented that aggressive privatization undermines the common school ideal, reduces essential public school funding, and ultimately threatens democratic citizenship.


UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): SDG 4: Quality Education; SDG 16: Peace, Justice, and Strong Institutions

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Fife, Brian. 2026. “The Legalization of School Choice and Its Implications for Public Education and Democratic Citizenship ”. Journal of Legal and Political Education 3 (1):111-34. https://doi.org/10.47305/jlpe.2026.2427.
Section
Review Articles
Author Biography

Brian Fife, Department of Political Science, Lehigh University, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, USA

Brian L. Fife is Professor and Chair of the Department of Political Science at Lehigh University in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, USA. His teaching focuses on American politics and public policy, while his current research examines the politics of reform. He is the author of Citizenship in the American Republic (2021), published by the University of Michigan Press, as well as several other books on education policy, U.S. elections, and social welfare policy.

References

Ballotpedia. 2026. "Party Control of Indiana State Government." [https://ballotpedia.org/Party_control_of_Indiana_state_government](https://ballotpedia.org/Party_control_of_Indiana_state_government).

Case Western Reserve University. 2025. "Encyclopedia of Cleveland History: Zelman v. Simmons-Harris." [https://case.edu/ech/articles/z/zelman-v-simmons-harris](https://case.edu/ech/articles/z/zelman-v-simmons-harris).

Center for Education Reform. 2025. "Laws and Legislation." [https://edreform.com/issue/choice-charter-schools/laws-legislation/](https://edreform.com/issue/choice-charter-schools/laws-legislation/).

Chambliss, J. J. 2003. "John Dewey's Philosophy of Education Before Democracy and Education." Education and Culture 19 (1): 1-7.

https://doi.org/10.7771/1559-1786.1455

Cohan, A., and C. F. Howlett. 2019. "The Historic Link between Horace Mann and John Dewey in Support of Public Schooling: A Lesson in Democracy." NJCSS Journal: Teaching Social Studies 19 (4). [https://teachingsocialstudies.org/2019/07/06/the-historic-link-between-horace-mann-and-john-dewey-in-support-of-public-schooling-a-lesson-in-democracy/](https://teachingsocialstudies.org/2019/07/06/the-historic-link-between-horace-mann-and-john-dewey-in-support-of-public-schooling-a-lesson-in-democracy/).

Connecticut General Assembly. 2022. "U.S. Supreme Court Decision in Carson v. Makin." September 1, 2022. [https://www.cga.ct.gov/2022/rpt/pdf/2022-R-0187.pdf](https://www.cga.ct.gov/2022/rpt/pdf/2022-R-0187.pdf).

Cremin, L. 1957. Horace Mann Lecture 1965: The Genius of American Education. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press. [Note: Titled "Lecture 1965" but dated 1957 in original entry].

Dewey, J. 2018. Democracy and Education: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Education. Gorham, ME: Myers Education Press.

Economic Policy Institute. 2024. "How Vouchers Harm Public Schools: Calculating the Costs of Voucher Programs to Public School Districts." December 19, 2024. [https://www.epi.org/publication/vouchers-harm-public-schools/](https://www.epi.org/publication/vouchers-harm-public-schools/).

EdChoice. 2025. "What Are School Vouchers?" www.edchoice.org/school-choice/types-of-school-choice/what-are-school-vouchers-2/.

Ferejohn, J. A., and M. P. Fiorina. 1974. "The Paradox of Not Voting: A Decision Theoretic Analysis." American Political Science Review 68 (2): 525-36.

https://doi.org/10.2307/1959502

Fife, B. 2004. "The U.S. Supreme Court and the Politics of Vouchers." International Journal of Educational Reform 13 (1): 74-83.

https://doi.org/10.1177/105678790401300107

Fife, B. 2013. Old School Still Matters: Lessons from History to Reform Public Education in America. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger.

https://doi.org/10.5040/9798400692895

Fife, B. 2016. "Renewing the American Commitment to the Common School Philosophy: School Choice in the Early Twenty-First Century." Global Education Review 3 (2): 4-22.

Fife, B. 2023. "Civic Education in the Academy." Education Reform Journal 8 (1). [http://dx.doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.8093191](http://dx.doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.8093191).

Groen, M. 2008. "The Whig Party and the Rise of Common Schools, 1837-1854." American Educational History Journal 35 (2): 251-60.

https://doi.org/10.1108/978-1-60752-818-020251020

Hinchey, Patricia H. 2018. "Introduction." In Democracy and Education: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Education, by John Dewey, xi-xx. Gorham, ME: Myers Education Press.

Indiana Department of Education. 2025. "Indiana Choice Scholarship Program." [https://www.in.gov/doe/students/indiana-choice-scholarship-program/](https://www.in.gov/doe/students/indiana-choice-scholarship-program/).

Indiana General Assembly. 2011. "Education." Indiana Code 20-51-4-4.

Indiana General Assembly. 2025. "Indiana Constitution." [https://iga.in.gov/laws/constitution](https://iga.in.gov/laws/constitution).

Indiana Supreme Court. 2025. "Justices of the Indiana Supreme Court." [https://www.in.gov/courts/supreme/files/justice-bios.pdf](https://www.in.gov/courts/supreme/files/justice-bios.pdf).

Indiana University, Center for Evaluation & Education Policy. 2015. "The Indiana Choice Scholarship Program: Legal Challenges, Program Expansion, and Participation." February 2015. [https://scholarworks.iu.edu/iuswrrest/api/core/bitstreams/99d7e109-01a3-4c2f-80c0-d3f09251974d/content](https://scholarworks.iu.edu/iuswrrest/api/core/bitstreams/99d7e109-01a3-4c2f-80c0-d3f09251974d/content).

Indianapolis Star. 2025. "Indiana Lawmakers Passed the State Budget Overnight: Here's Who Wins and Who Loses." April 25, 2025. [https://www.indystar.com/story/news/politics/2025/04/25/indiana-lawmakers-passed-a-state-budget-heres-who-wins-and-who-loses/83254354007/](https://www.indystar.com/story/news/politics/2025/04/25/indiana-lawmakers-passed-a-state-budget-heres-who-wins-and-who-loses/83254354007/).

Karapin, R., and L. Feldman. 2016. "Unintended Consequences." Polity 48 (4): 441-44.

https://doi.org/10.1057/s41279-016-0005-5

Ladd, E. C. 1978. Where Have All the Voters Gone?: The Fracturing of America's Political Parties. New York: W. W. Norton.

Laitsch, D. 2016. "After 60 Years, Do the Arguments for K-12 Vouchers Still Hold?" Global Education Review 3 (2): 23-32.

Library of Congress. 2025. "Jefferson's Letter to the Danbury Baptists, January 1, 1802." [https://www.loc.gov/loc/lcib/9806/danpre.html](https://www.loc.gov/loc/lcib/9806/danpre.html).

Mann, H. 1891. The Life and Works of Horace Mann. 5 vols. Boston, MA: Lee and Shepard.

Mencimer, S. 2016. "Mike Pence's Voucher Program in Indiana Was a Windfall for Religious Schools." Mother Jones, December 2, 2016. [https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2016/12/mike-pence-voucher-program-religious-schools/](https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2016/12/mike-pence-voucher-program-religious-schools/).

Messerli, J. 1971. Horace Mann: A Biography. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.

Minnesota Legislative Reference Library. 2026. "Charter Schools." [https://www.lrl.mn.gov/guides/guides?issue=charter](https://www.lrl.mn.gov/guides/guides?issue=charter).

Morgan, J. E. 1936. Horace Mann: His Ideas and Ideals. Washington, DC: National Home Library Foundation.

National Archives and Records Administration. 2025. "The House Selects a President." [https://www.archives.gov/exhibits/treasures_of_congress/text/page7_text.html](https://www.archives.gov/exhibits/treasures_of_congress/text/page7_text.html).

Network for Public Education. 2023. "In Fact or Fallacy?: An In-Depth Critique of the CREDO 2023 National Report." www.networkforpubliceducation.org/factorfallacy/.

O'Connor, M. 2015. "State Constitutional Law-Education-Why Voucher Programs Do Not Erase the Connection Between Church and State." Rutgers University Law Review 67: 1271-88.

Pew Research Center. 2024. "Voters' and Nonvoters' Experiences with the 2024 Election." [https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2024/12/04/voters-and-nonvoters-experiences-with-the-2024-election/](https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2024/12/04/voters-and-nonvoters-experiences-with-the-2024-election/).

Ravitch, D. 2014. Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America's Public Schools. New York: Vintage Books.

Renier, S. 2016. "The Many Lives of John Dewey's Democracy and Education: A Historical Account of the Reception of a Book Still to Be Read." European Journal of Pragmatism and American Philosophy 8 (1): 1-16.

https://doi.org/10.4000/ejpap.448

Shepherd Express. 2009. "An Interview with Educator and Activist Jonathan Kozol." March 4, 2009. [https://shepherdexpress.com/news/features/interview-educator-activist-jonathan-kozol/](https://shepherdexpress.com/news/features/interview-educator-activist-jonathan-kozol/).

Sigelman, L. 1982. "The Nonvoting Voter in Voting Research." American Journal of Political Science 26 (1): 47-56.

https://doi.org/10.2307/2110838

Stanford University, Center for Research on Education Outcomes. 2009. "Multiple Choice: Charter School Performance in 16 States." [https://credo.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/multiple_choice_credo.pdf](https://credo.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/multiple_choice_credo.pdf).

Stanford University, Center for Research on Education Outcomes. 2013. "National Charter School Study 2013." [https://credo.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/ncss_2013_final_draft.pdf](https://credo.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/ncss_2013_final_draft.pdf).

Stanford University, Center for Research on Education Outcomes. 2023. "As a Matter of Fact: The National Charter School Study 2023." [https://credo.stanford.edu/reports/item/national-charter-school-study-iii/](https://credo.stanford.edu/reports/item/national-charter-school-study-iii/).

StateImpact Indiana. 2016. "Five Years Later, Indiana's Voucher Program Functions Very Differently." August 19, 2016. [https://indianapublicmedia.org/stateimpact/2016/08/19/years-indianas-voucher-program-functions-differently/](https://indianapublicmedia.org/stateimpact/2016/08/19/years-indianas-voucher-program-functions-differently/).

The Keene Sentinel. 2023. "Sununu Signs Bill Expanding School Voucher Program." June 27, 2023. [https://www.keenesentinel.com/news/local/sununu-signs-bill-expanding-school-voucher-program/article_fa7ff8a0-da6a-5dcc-b8a8-676e39600cda.html](https://www.keenesentinel.com/news/local/sununu-signs-bill-expanding-school-voucher-program/article_fa7ff8a0-da6a-5dcc-b8a8-676e39600cda.html).

Thomas Jefferson's Monticello. 2025. "Jefferson's Religious Beliefs." [https://www.monticello.org/research-education/thomas-jefferson-encyclopedia/jeffersons-religious-beliefs/](https://www.monticello.org/research-education/thomas-jefferson-encyclopedia/jeffersons-religious-beliefs/).

University of Colorado, National Education Policy Center. 2023. "CREDO Report Makes Overstated Claims of Charter School Gains." [https://nepc.colorado.edu/publication-announcement/2023/09/charter-study](https://nepc.colorado.edu/publication-announcement/2023/09/charter-study).

University of Florida, Election Lab. 2026. "2024 General Election Turnout." [https://election.lab.ufl.edu/2024-general-election-turnout/](https://election.lab.ufl.edu/2024-general-election-turnout/).

University of Vermont. 2025. "Tuition Vouchers." [https://www.uvm.edu/d10-files/documents/2025-01/Tuition-Vouchers.pdf](https://www.uvm.edu/d10-files/documents/2025-01/Tuition-Vouchers.pdf).

Wattenberg, M. 2002. Where Have All the Voters Gone? Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. [https://www.hup.harvard.edu/books/9780674009387](https://www.hup.harvard.edu/books/9780674009387)

Williams, M. 2017. "John Dewey in the 21st Century." Journal of Inquiry & Action in Education 9 (1): 91-102.

Williams, T. 2018. Hamilton: An American Biography. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

Ye, Yan-Hong, and Yi-Huang Shih. 2021. "Development of John Dewey's Educational Philosophy and Its Implications for Children's Education." Policy Futures in Education 19 (8): 877-90.

https://doi.org/10.1177/1478210320987678

Table of Cases

Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, KS, 347 U.S. 483 (1954).

Carson v. Makin, 596 U.S. 767 (2022).

Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, 558 U.S. 310 (2010).

Everson v. Board of Education of the Township of Ewing, 330 U.S. 1 (1947).

Green v. County School Board of New Kent County, VA, 391 U.S. 430 (1968).

McCollum v. Board of Education of School District No. 71, Champaign County, IL, 333 U.S. 203 (1948).

Meredith v. Pence, 984 N.E.2d 1213 (Ind. 2013).

Mueller v. Allen, 463 U.S. 388 (1983).

Witters v. Washington Department of Services for the Blind, 474 U.S. 481 (1986).

Zelman v. Simmons-Harris, 536 U.S. 639 (2002).

Zobrest v. Catalina Foothills School District, 509 U.S. 1 (1993).